Welcome

Monday, 5 January 2026

The Gig-Economy of Nickel: An Ethnographic Analysis of Indonesia’s EV Transition


Source: https://universe.roboflow.com/zihan-septi/klasifikasi-plat-kendaraan


While the global discourse on the nickel value chain focuses on upstream mining and downstream processing, a critical gap remains in understanding the "final mile": the ride-hailing drivers. Since 2020, Indonesia’s energy transition has moved from a conceptual pilot to a large-scale institutional investment, accelerated by the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) Regulation No. 13/2020.

For platforms like Gojek (GoTo) and Grab, this transition reflects an integrated asset-management strategy. By leveraging entities like Electrum or third-party providers, these platforms maintain centralized control over critical operational assets, thereby transforming the driver’s role from an asset owner to a long-term lessee.

Economic Necessity over Ecological Choice

For many drivers, the switch to Electric Vehicles (EVs) is rarely driven by environmental awareness. Instead, it is a pragmatic response to financial precarity. Most drivers who opt for EV fleets, such as Daur (a pseudonym), do so because they do not own a private vehicle and require an immediate source of income without the high upfront cost of purchasing a motorcycle. The EV rental scheme provides a "quick entry" into the labor market for those in urgent need of liquidity, despite the long-term structural dependencies it creates.

The Opearting Lease

The core of this transition is the "operating lease" system. Drivers pay a daily rental fee of approximately IDR 75,000 for the vehicle and battery. In this model, ownership remains strictly with the lessor.

For a driver like Daur, the day begins with a "debt." Working 12 hours a day, he nets roughly IDR 170,000. While this is slightly more profitable than using internal combustion engines (ICE) due to rising fuel costs, the margins are fragile. The promised quarterly and biannual incentives act as a digital "carrot," disciplining drivers into long-term rental commitments to the platform's ecosystem.

Technical Constraints and Corporal Stress

The ethnographic reality on the ground reveals a "Battery Discipline." The quality of battery cells varies across brands despite uniform rental costs. Drivers face a constant anxiety: the Battery Swapping Station (BSS) network is unevenly distributed. A depleted battery mid-trip is not just a technical failure; it is a reputational risk. In the platform economy, a dead battery potentially leads to 1-star ratings, reduced order priority, and the threat of account suspension—a "digital death" for their livelihood.

Gendered Impact for The Driver

The burden is disproportionately felt by female drivers. The physical design of many EV units—bulky and heavy—is not ergonomic for smaller frames. Furthermore, the "flexibility" of the gig economy reveals its rigidity in times of illness or biological needs. With a strict "3 days off per month" rule and no formal leave (such as menstrual leave), female drivers must continue paying the daily IDR 75,000 rent even when they are physically unable to work.

Conclusion: The Risk of Energy Transition

The drivers are not luddites; they do not reject the energy transition. However, they are caught in a pincer move between national emission targets and the platform's asset-management strategies.

This represents a significant socio-economic and health risk.. As Indonesia pushes for "Net Zero 2060," the sustainability of the EV ecosystem depends on whether the burden of transition is shared or merely offloaded onto the most vulnerable actors in the value chain.

No comments:

Post a Comment

My Services

Journalistic
Project Management
Research, MEL, and Assessment
Communication Strategist
Translation
Book Editing

Wanna collaborate?

Selected Portfolios

I am an award-winning journalist and researcher with a cross-sectoral and interdisciplinary background grounded in anthropology. I consider myself a data-driven insight generator and storyteller, combining qualitative research with quantitative data analysis to produce meaningful, evidence-based narratives. Alongside my academic training, I have completed intensive courses in data analysis, project management, content creation, and digital safety, which inform my applied and practice-oriented work.

I have received multiple awards for journalism and research. In 2025, I was awarded by the Earth Journalism Network and Progresip for a short-video report titled Mendengar Suara Pekerja untuk Transisi Energi: Motor Listrik antara Beban dan Harapan Driver Ojol. In 2019, I received research awards from Universitas Gadjah Mada, Chiang Mai University, and Vienna University for research conducted in Thailand. I was also recognized by the Indonesia Territorial Conference as a Top Book Reviewer. Earlier, in 2015, I received an award from Universitas Gadjah Mada for my research titled Agroforestry Transformation and Totemism in West Borneo.

My career spans roles as a researcher, journalist, data analyst, content director, trainer, and public relations professional, working across academia, policy, media, civil society, and companies.

Below is a selection of my publications and projects:

1) Media and Journalism:

2) Academic Works:

3) Assesment and Edit:

  • Asesmen Dampak Proyek NICFI – Samdhana Institute “Hak Komunitas dan REDD+ di Indonesia” (Impact assessment, 2016–2021 — offline publication)
  • Recommendations for the Improvement of the Indigenous Peoples (Masyarakat Hukum Adat) Regional Regulation of Asmat Regency, Papua (Assessment — offline publication)
  • Jaminan Sosial di Indonesia: Sejarah, Teori, dan Tantangan Masa Depan (Editor)
    https://library.fes.de/pdf-files/bueros/indonesien/21813.pdf
  • Kronik Undang-Undang Desa: dari UU No. 5/1979 tentang Pemerintahan Desa ke UU No. 6 tentang Desa (Editor — offline publication)

4) Market Insight, Translation, and Communication Strategy:

  • Potential Customer Analysis (Market Research — Confidental thrifting client; offline publication)
  • How Clients Choose Agencies (Market Research — Confidental agnecy client ; offline publication)
  • The Romance of a Busy Broker — O. Henry (Literary translation; co-translated with Silmi Afina — offline)
    Indonesian version: Kisah cinta pialang saham yang sibuk
  • Pulung Gantung (Movie subtitle translation, Javanese–English; with Yasmin — offline)
  • Katanya anti-diskriminasi, tapi kok masih terjadi?” — Kampanye Kilo 190 (Instagram content lead / communication strategy)
    Link Instagram
  • Interactive Map: Top Coffee Producing and Consuming Countries (2025) (Strategic communication)
    View Dashboard
  • Empat Puluh Tokoh Alumni Pers Mahasiswa UGM (Publlic Relation — offline)
  • Tempat Wisata di Jambi yang harus Kamu Kunjungi (Tourism promotion)
    wisatadestinasi.com